Star photography

So here’s the question – which of the following 2 photos do you prefer ? The top one is a long exposure of 1.5 hours which shows how the stars have moved during this time … it’s not been Photoshopped in any way but looks a tad unrealistic ? Or the bottom photo is just an expousre of about 30 seconds but with a bit of foreground light added from my car headlights shining through the tree. So which is it ? A) top;or  B) bottom @Ianwoodphotos Thanls to eveyone who replied via Twitter … the verdict was about 60/40 in favour of the bottom photo.